- Shields
- Shiell
- Shiells
- James (abt 1802 - Jan 1883)
- James (abt 1846 - aft 1883)
- Shike
- Shill
- Shillabeer
- Hilda (abt 1882 - aft 1901)
- John (bet Mar 1858 and Jun 1858 - bet Jun 1891 and Sep 1891)
- Shillibeer
- Shipley
- Shoemaker
- Hester (abt 1772 - bet Jan 1860 and Mar 1860)
- Shortell
- Shortreed
- Shortridge
- Shotter
- Shute
- Emily (abt 1875 - aft 1901)
- Sills
- Silver
- Simmons
- Simmonsen
- Simons
- Daisy (Mar 1898 - Jun 1976)
- Simpson
- Sims
- Sinclair
- Sincock
- Sinton